--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other Ingredients
Each potion consists of an identified herb, and another ingredient to mix in with it. You need to combine the correct ingredients together to make the potion of your choice, and many of the ingredients can be looted from enemies. Others may require you to venture into the Wilderness to find them.
Ingredient Chart
Item & Picture Where to Obtain
Eye of Newt Bought: Taverley Herblore Shop, Port Sarim Magic Emporium.
Dropped By: Zombies
Unicorn Horn Normal: Unicorns; ground the horn with a Pestle and Mortar.
Ground: Chaos Druid Warriors
Limpwurt Root Dropped By: Hobgoblins and Giants
Ashes Dropped By: Demons and Imps; they'll also appear from an extinguished fire.
Red Spider's Eggs Respawn: Karamja Volcano and the Varrock Sewers past the giant spider web.
Blamish Snail Slime Obtained: Kill & cook a Mort Myre Snail, grind it with a Pestle while carrying a Test Bottle with you.
Chocolate Bar Bought: Port Sarim Grocery Store, Gnome Stronghold, Culinaromancer's Chest in Lumbridge
Respawn: South of the Lost City of Zanaris bank, Cook's Guild.
White Berries Respawn: Level 37-40 Wilderness in the Red Dragon Isle. Be careful of the Red Dragons wandering around!
Dropped By: Cave Crawlers
Toad Legs Respawn: The Gnome Stronghold Swamp, southeast of Jatix's Herblore shop in Taverley; remove the legs from the Toads.
Snape Grass Respawn: Hobgoblin area just west of the Crafting Guild.
Dropped By: Tribesman on Karamja Island.
Mort Myre Fungi Respawn: Use your Druid Spell near any log in the Mort Myre Swamp and pick the fungi.
Blue Dragon Scale Respawn: In the chamber home to the Blue Dragons in the Taverley Member's Dungeon.
Wine of Zamorak Respawn: On the altar in the Temple of Zamorak. You must cast the Telekinetic Grab spell on the wine to get it. Or, just kill all of the Monks of Zamorak, pray at the Chaos Altar and then take the wine.
Potato Cactus Respawn: In the Kalphite Lair, in the chamber west of the room leading to the second level of the cave.
Jangerberries Respawn: On the island just west of Yanille. You can either use Telekinetic Grab to take them, or bring a rope to swing across the river (requires 30 Agility).
Tree Roots Obtained: Chop down a tree (Yew or Magic) and use a spade on the stump to dig out the roots. Note: You must have farmed the tree yourself to get a tree root from it.
Cactus Spine Obtained: Farmed by you or another player.
Poison Ivy Berry Obtained: Farmed by you or another player.
Crushed Bird Nest Obtained: Bird nests sometimes fall out of trees while chopping them down. Just use a Pestle and Mortar with the nest to crush it.
Coconut Milk Obtained: Use a Hammer on a Coconut to crack it open. then use the open coconut with an empty Vial to fill it with Coconut Milk. Coconuts can be Farmed or traded from other players.
Garlic Obtained: Can be found in a house in Draynor, or in a chest in the Burgh De Rott Inn.
Silver Dust Obtained: Made by crushing a Silver Bar in the bone grinder in Port Phasmatys.
Nightshade Obtained: During the Watchtower Quest.
Grown: From the Farming skill.
Gorak Claw Obtained: Sometimes dropped by Goraks.
Kebbit Teeth Dust Obtained: Catch a Sabre-toothed Kebbit with your Hunter skill and use a Pestle and Mortar with it's teeth.
Starflower Obtained: Obtained during the Cure a Queen Quest.
Ground Goat's Horn Obtained: Use a Pestle and Mortar on a Goat's Horn. Goats can be found in the desert, north of Sophanem, near the Kalphite entrance, to the west and north of Nardah, and near Uzer.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------